Edified’s 2026 Enquiry Experience Tracker, released today, is based on 887 mystery-shopped domestic student enquiries across 63 institutions in Australia and the UK. The headline is that just 37% of students were very likely to continue engaging with a university after making an enquiry. The research suggests the problem isn’t that universities are routinely getting things badly wrong. Only 15% of students reported a genuinely negative experience. Instead, institutions are struggling to turn an ordinary enquiry into an experience that actually gives a prospective student a reason to keep talking.
That middle ground is something worth pondering.
Because there is a particular kind of bad customer experience that doesn’t generate a complaint.
It doesn’t prompt a furious email. It doesn’t produce a one-star review. It doesn’t even necessarily cause someone to walk away immediately.
It is simply… fine.
And according to the Edified research, “fine” may be costing universities a considerable number of prospective students.
In a competitive market, students have plenty of options. They don’t necessarily need an institution to make a spectacular mistake before moving on. Sometimes they simply need another university to make a better impression.
As Elissa Newall, Senior Partner and EET Project Director at Edified, says, “Students aren’t walking away because they got bad information; they’re on the fence because universities don’t give them enough confidence to take the next step.
“Warmth and a properly tailored answer show that you value the student, and in both Australia and the UK, too few institutions are consistently getting that right,” she says.
The basics are still doing the heavy lifting
For all the investment in CRM systems, digital journeys, automation and increasingly sophisticated recruitment technology, the research points back to some remarkably old-fashioned principles.
Reply to the student.
Answer the questions.
Sound like a human being.
Show that you have actually read what they asked.
And, perhaps most importantly, give them a reason to come back.
The data suggests students were seven times more likely to continue engaging when the response was tailored to them.
Yet only around half of responses achieved the right tone, while roughly two-thirds answered all of the questions asked.
That is a fairly significant gap between what universities know they should be doing and what prospective students are actually experiencing.
It also raises a fairly simple question.
If a student has taken the time to make contact, why wouldn’t the response be personalised?
The answer may be operational efficiency. Templates are quicker. Automated responses are scalable. Enquiry teams are busy.
But from the student’s perspective, none of that matters.
They asked a question.
They wanted an answer.
Being nice isn’t enough. But it helps.
One of the strongest findings in the research is the relationship between warmth and continued engagement.
Four in five students who experienced warmth, care and reassurance left with a favourable impression of the institution.
That shouldn’t come as a surprise. But it is worth remembering at a time when universities are increasingly focused on the mechanics of recruitment.
A prospective student isn’t just trying to establish whether a Bachelor of Business has eight majors.
They are trying to work out whether they can see themselves there.
That is where seemingly small things matter.
Does someone sound interested?
Do they understand the student’s circumstances?
Do they answer the question behind the question?
Do they make the student feel welcome?
The study includes comments from mystery shoppers that demonstrate the difference.
“It felt like they really tried to understand my needs…”
And from an Australian parent:
“He was warm, engaging, personable. It was one of the best emotional connections I’ve had from a uni.”
Universities have become very good at building the funnel.
The human being entering it can still get lost somewhere near the top.
Speed matters. Apparently, students have noticed the internet.
Another fairly obvious finding is that students increasingly expect a fast response.
Nearly one in four web enquiries received a response within four business hours.
That may not sound particularly remarkable. It does when you consider the environment students live in.
They can order dinner in minutes, track a parcel across the country, speak to a bank through an app and ask ChatGPT a complicated question before their coffee gets cold.
A university taking two or three days to answer a straightforward enquiry can therefore feel less like considered service and more like a system that hasn’t quite caught up.
Phone remains the strongest channel in both Australia and the UK.
Instagram, meanwhile, appears to be something of a black hole.
One in five Instagram enquiries went unanswered, and even when universities did respond, conversations rarely progressed beyond the first exchange.
The research’s characterisation of Instagram as a place where universities “go quiet” is difficult to argue with.
If an institution invites prospective students to contact it on a channel, it probably needs to actually answer them there.
The follow-up problem is hiding in plain sight
Perhaps the biggest missed opportunity in the research is what happens after the initial question has been answered.
More than half of students, 52%, never heard from the institution again.
That is a remarkable number.
The student has raised their hand. The university has responded. The immediate question has been dealt with.
And then… nothing.
This is where recruitment and customer service collide.
An enquiry isn’t necessarily a request for a piece of information. It can be the beginning of a relationship.
The student may be comparing three universities. They may be unsure about their course choice. They may be worried about entry requirements. They may be trying to convince a parent. They may simply need another nudge.
The research puts it neatly: institutions can lose momentum at precisely the point when a prospect needs nurturing rather than another answer.
The irony is that follow-up is one of the easiest things to systematise.
Yet it appears to be one of the things universities are doing least consistently.
And then there is AI
Perhaps the most uncomfortable part of the research is the comparison with ChatGPT.
Mystery shoppers submitted the same enquiry to universities and ChatGPT.
71% preferred the AI response.
That does not mean students suddenly prefer talking to robots.
It suggests something more interesting.
The AI responses were generally clearer, better structured, more comprehensive and more persuasive.
ChatGPT provided a genuine reason to choose the institution in 50% of responses, compared with just 30% for university responses.
Students also reported feeling more positive about the institution after reading the AI response.
That should probably make a few enquiry managers uncomfortable.
Universities have an obvious advantage over AI. They actually know their institution. They know their courses, campuses, communities and people. They can understand an individual’s circumstances and make a judgement about what might matter to them.
But those advantages don’t automatically appear in an email.
If the university response is a generic paragraph followed by a link to the website, while AI delivers a clear, personalised and comprehensive answer in seconds, the human advantage starts looking rather theoretical.
The answer isn’t to try to beat AI at being AI.
It is to be better at being human.
Australia is doing some things differently
The Australian results were stronger overall than the UK, with Australia recording a score of 63 compared with 57 for the UK.
Australian institutions were also stronger on responsiveness and follow-up.
There is one particularly interesting difference in the way the two markets approach one-to-one engagement.
Around 60% of Australian institutions offered one-to-one consultations, compared with just 12% in the UK.
And those consultations produced the strongest result of any channel tested, with 94% of students saying they would continue engaging afterwards.
That is a useful reminder that digital recruitment doesn’t necessarily mean removing people from the process.
Sometimes the most effective digital strategy is getting the right person in front of the right student.
The gap between good and great is where the money is
The most interesting part of the research isn’t really that some universities provide poor enquiry experiences.
It is that relatively few appear to consistently provide exceptional ones.
When all five fundamentals are delivered- a response, completeness, the right tone, inspiration and follow-up — the results change dramatically.
97% of students leave with a positive impression and 94% say they are very likely to continue engaging.
That is the difference between answering an enquiry and doing something with it.
And this is where the research becomes particularly relevant for a sector facing tighter recruitment conditions and growing competition for domestic students.
Universities don’t necessarily need more leads.
They need to extract more value from the leads they already have.
That means treating an enquiry as something more than a task to clear from the CRM.
It is a recruitment opportunity.
It is also one of the few parts of the recruitment journey an institution can directly control.
The student has already done the hard bit.
They’ve reached out.
The question is what happens next.
Because “fine” might be good enough for customer service.
It probably isn’t good enough for recruitment.
View the Edified Experience Tracker report here.











